Post Reply 

Are Gimp's “color space” blend modes the same as those in Photoshop?

Jun 23, 2011, 15:14
Post: #1
Are Gimp's “color space” blend modes the same as those in Photoshop?
I asked this question over on Photography Stack Exchange, but maybe someone here will know better. (If you can answer the question there, that'd be double-super awesome.) But anyway:


The Wikipedia article on Blend Modes describes three of blend modes in particular like this:

Quote:Photoshop’s hue, saturation, color, and luminosity blend modes are based on a color space with dimensions that the article HSL and HSV calls hue, chroma, and luma. Note that this space is different from both HSL and HSV, and only the hue dimension is shared between the three; see that article for details. [...] Because these blend modes are based on a color space which is much closer than RGB to perceptually relevant dimensions, it can be used to correct the color of an image without altering perceived lightness, and to manipulate lightness contrast without changing the hue or chroma. The Luminosity mode is commonly used for image sharpening, because human vision is much more sensitive to fine-scale lightness contrast than color contrast.

and, without references, adds:

Quote:Few editors other than Photoshop implement this same color space for their analogs of these blend modes. Instead, they typically base their blend modes on HSV (aka HSB) or HSL. Blend modes based on HSV are typically labeled hue, saturation, and brightness. Using HSL or HSV has the advantage that most operations become invertible (at least in theory), but the disadvantage that the dimensions of HSL and HSV are not as perceptually relevant as the dimensions of the space Photoshop uses.

In my version of Gimp, those options are Hue, Saturation, Color, and Value. This isn't exactly the same as the terminology used in Photoshop (value replaces luminosity), but it's also not "hue, saturation, and brightness" as in the paragraph above.

As the Wikipedia article explains it, the color space Photoshop uses here would appear to be an advantage for photography, since it's more perceptually-relevant. Which does Gimp use?
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
Jun 24, 2011, 22:46
Post: #2
RE: Are Gimp's “color space” blend modes the same as those in Photoshop?
Yes. The Photoshop terminology might be different but the color blending modes in GIMP do the exact same thing. GIMP has a couple of extra bending modes that Photoshop does not.
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
Jun 24, 2011, 23:10
Post: #3
RE: Are Gimp's “color space” blend modes the same as those in Photoshop?
(Jun 24, 2011 22:46)Troysgfx Wrote:  Yes. The Photoshop terminology might be different but the color blending modes in GIMP do the exact same thing. GIMP has a couple of extra bending modes that Photoshop does not.
Then what is really the "Color" more? The doc says it transfers Hue and Saturation, but it obviously doesn't really transfer the saturation.

Now answering your questions on
https://Gimp-Forum.net
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread: Author Replies: Views: Last Post
  Comparability with Photoshop: layer styles jimmyspenser 2 395 Jul 24, 2014 15:46
Last Post: Esper
  Version question ? adobe photoshop? awweeks 6 509 May 21, 2014 08:25
Last Post: rich2005
  Photoshop Layer Styles Witention 1 748 Apr 24, 2014 03:16
Last Post: iForStyle007
  Why Gimp is slower that Photoshop? Copiche 1 446 Apr 23, 2014 13:11
Last Post: ofnuts
  psB file support? (BIG photoshop format) darlingm 1 1,330 Apr 1, 2014 07:01
Last Post: iForStyle007

Forum Jump:


GIMP ForumPortalArchiveContactTermsRSS